Yesterday I finished one of the comprehensive exams required for my DM degree (Doctor of Music - specializing in composition). Passing all three will admit me to DM candidacy (essentially an all but dissertation state). It is considered a major hurdle - I have several friends who have failed at least one of their exams once (you can take each exam a total of two times) though I do not know of anyone who has totally flunked out because of it.
These exams have been a major monkey on my back.
I finishes my course work three years ago. A normal student will then take their exams in the year following the completion of their course work (some even do them in the final year of course work). I don't know of anyone who waited three years to do them - and I haven't even done all three yet. See, the exams are administered by a committee put together by myself of professors I have a relationship with. Each professor then works out a "question" to be prepared for and then asked about for the exam, followed by orals a week or so later. Normally, a student does all three questions at the same time and completes the orals in front of the entire committee. Normally, the chair of a student's committee doesn't leave the school for greener pastures in the middle of all this, yet that is what happened to me. The chair of my committee is (was?) an extraordinary teacher and composer and a very sweet, friendly woman. She did not have a tenure track position, so when she found one in Pittsburgh, she of course took it. Security is a nice thing, no? When I found out about this in April, my stomach sank.
This past year, I had been trying somewhat valiantly to get all of my committee members to work with me, get my questions in order and get my preparation for them underway so I could get them out of the way. For whatever reason, two of these professors (neither of which was the one who is leaving) were really crappy about getting back to me - I finally had to get the dean involved. I then got sidetracked when Jessie and I were searching for a home to buy. Getting the email about my professor leaving got me back on the studying track, but by then it was too late for me to be prepared to write all three questions before she left. Luckily, because a committee member leaving is a somewhat unusual situation, I was given the option of writing her question alone, or doing all three. You can guess what my choice was. I got my shit for her in order, then realized that I was going to have to write the exam (I chose to do a week long take-home) the week after Jessie and I moved into our new home. Stressful! I felt like such a deadbeat, seeing the boxes piled up, the mess accumulating, Katie needing attention not just in the day but also in the evening when Jessie was home - yet I had an exam to write and a very real deadline. I somehow managed to get it done (30 pages of text! one week! several hours of library research in there too!) and mostly kept a good mood despite several near sleepless nights (and I still had to get up a 7:00 AM everyday - no sleeping in allowed by the Katie). Jessie was wonderful throughout, dutifully watching Katie each evening and putting her to bed to allow me to concentrate and write. Yesterday I did the oral component which was much less strenuous but still pretty stressful. Then my professor hugged me, told me that I passed and that she would write a letter for me file to that effect and wished me all the best (and vice versa).
I'll miss her - she was one of the few professors at school that I really bonded with. It is to my great regret that due to my procrastinating ways I did not take advantage of her presence much the last three years and that I will now have to finish out my degree without her support and oversight. It's a hard lesson to learn. I understand that in the big picture, finding a new committee chair is not that bad - procrastination can cause people their homes, jobs, even lives in particularly extreme cases - so I am thankful to have a relatively gentle bad result from my put-it-off ways - but still, it is discouraging.
How frustrating is it, that of all the composition professors I have studied with in graduate school, the three best have all left the school, the fourth best has died, and the worst two are the ones who are left?
Still, I don't want to end on a negative note. It is very satisfying to have made tangible, forward progress after so much wheel spinning. The other two questions look to be even more manageable than this one was, and I now have the summer to get myself good and ready for it. One down, two to go.
Recent Comments